What an extension adds, and what it costs
A downloader extension injects a script into Facebook pages and looks for video URLs as the page loads. When it works, you get a download button next to the player. The costs are real, though: it needs permission to read and change data on every page it runs on, it has to be updated every time Facebook changes its markup, and a discontinued extension keeps its permissions until you remove it.
The three ways extensions fail
- Markup drift. Facebook changes its player regularly. An extension that is not maintained stops finding video URLs — usually silently, with the button simply doing nothing.
- Manifest rules. Browser policy changes periodically restrict what extensions may inject, and older downloaders are retired because of it.
- Abandonment. A popular extension with no recent updates is a liability, not a tool. The listing stays up long after the developer has moved on.
What no extension can do
Two things, and both matter. First, an extension cannot read a private or friends-only video — the media is not sent to your browser, so there is nothing for it to capture. Second, it cannot beat the resolution Facebook will not serve you. If you are not logged in and the post is restricted, the file simply is not on your machine to grab.
The no-install route
When an extension is still the better choice
If you download dozens of videos a day from the same site, a maintained extension with a good update history can save clicks. The practical test is the update log: an extension that shipped a fix in the last couple of months is being cared for; one whose last release is two years old is not.